Bigger House, Bigger Bill – Same Results?

U.S. House of Representatives seal on a glass door
Photo: DCStockPhotography / Shutterstock

A media figure just called to add hundreds of seats to Congress to blunt the Electoral College — without changing the Constitution.

Story Snapshot

  • Chuck Todd urged expanding the House to about 800 seats to curb Electoral College-popular vote splits.
  • Congressional research confirms House size is set by law, not the Constitution, so Congress could change it.
  • Peer-reviewed work shows bigger Houses reduce, but do not end, election “inversions”.
  • Most Americans do not want a larger House, according to national polling.

What Todd Proposed and Why It Matters

Chuck Todd wrote that Congress should “uncap” the House to about 800 members to stop Electoral College and popular vote splits. He claimed this fix needs no constitutional amendment and would make the House “the people’s House” again. The appeal targets presidential races where the Electoral College differs from the national vote. The idea also signals a broader push by some on the left to rewrite rules that protect smaller states and balance power across regions.

Congressional research backs one core point: the Constitution does not lock the House at 435 seats. Federal law sets the number, so Congress could raise it by statute. Separate research outlines how seats are apportioned by population after each census, with each state guaranteed at least one representative. Changing House size would ripple into the Electoral College because each state’s electors equal House seats plus two senators. That is the lever Todd wants to pull.

What the Evidence Says About Expanding the House

Peer-reviewed analysis finds that enlarging the House can reduce the chance that one candidate wins the Electoral College while losing the popular vote, but it does not eliminate that risk. Even with very large Houses, close races can still invert due to winner-take-all rules in states. Other modeling reports little reliable partisan advantage from expansion, which undercuts claims that one side would lock in gains by adding seats alone. These findings caution against big promises and quick fixes.

Commentary that is supportive of reform still flags trade-offs. Adding hundreds of districts would force new maps. That opens more chances for gerrymandering unless lawmakers pair expansion with tough guardrails. Without those rules, power brokers in state capitals could carve districts to entrench control. That would not make Congress closer to the people. It would deepen mistrust and sew confusion in election years already strained by culture fights and media spin.

What Voters Think and What Conservatives Should Watch

Polling shows most Americans do not want a bigger House. A 2023 survey found 53 percent want to keep the House at 435 seats, 29 percent would increase it, and 15 percent want fewer members. That skepticism makes sense. Taxpayers see a federal government that already spends too much and reaches too far. Adding hundreds of new lawmakers, offices, and staffs would raise costs, swell bureaucracy, and make Washington even more distant from families and small towns.

Conservatives should track three risks. First, eroding the Electoral College weakens smaller states and rural voices, the very balance the system was built to protect. Second, a larger House, without strict anti-gerrymander rules, could harden partisan maps and drown out local communities. Third, promises that 800 seats would “solve” inversions oversell the math; research says inversions can still happen in tight races. Rule changes must secure liberty and fairness, not tilt the field.

Bottom Line for 2026

Todd’s plan rides a real mechanism: Congress can change House size by law. But the pitch that 800 members would end Electoral College-popular vote splits goes beyond what solid research supports. Voters are wary of a bigger Congress and the costs that come with it. President Trump’s administration should press reforms that strengthen election integrity, defend the Constitution’s balance, and keep power close to the people — not bulk up Washington for a speculative payoff.

Sources:

twitchy.com, congress.gov, dailykos.com, paulschiffberman.substack.com, blumenauer.house.gov, delawareonline.com, washingtonexaminer.com