A Florida records review says 1,827 people removed as noncitizens cast 7,035 ballots since 2020, raising urgent questions about election integrity.
Story Snapshot
- Volunteer analysts say records show 1,827 removed noncitizens cast 7,035 ballots statewide.
- Review covered all 67 counties and used official state and county records, per reports.
- County officials say they cannot validate the totals without the underlying dataset.
- Past cases show database errors are possible, so full verification is key.
What The Florida Report Claims And Why It Matters
Volunteer researchers from election integrity groups say they reviewed public records from all 67 Florida counties and found that 5,612 people were removed from voter rolls as noncitizens, including 1,827 tied to 7,035 ballots from 2020 through mid-2026. They say they relied on county election files, state motor vehicle records, and Florida’s Office of Election Crimes and Security records. The report’s authors argue the alleged ballots could have affected close races in some counties, including local and congressional contests, if confirmed.
The claim strikes at a core principle: only citizens vote. Florida law requires supervisors to keep rolls clean and remove ineligible voters after notice and review. The groups say their work shows gaps that allowed years of ballots tied to people later removed as noncitizens. They press for answers on who knew what, when notices went out, and whether any ballots were counted in races with tight margins. They also call for a full audit of the underlying records by neutral experts.
How Officials Responded And What Is Still Unclear
Several county offices did not confirm or reject the numbers. Palm Beach County said they could not verify outside conclusions without seeing the data that backs them up. Baker County’s supervisor said he was unaware of noncitizen voting during his time in office and noted that flagged voters get a chance to respond or request a hearing before any removal. That process matters, because a database flag alone does not prove ineligibility at the time a ballot was cast.
Prior Florida history shows why careful checks are needed. A large 2012 statewide list of potential noncitizens was narrowed from about 180,000 to about 2,700 apparent discrepancies for local review, and media later found nearly 100 actual noncitizens. That pattern teaches two things. First, some noncitizen voting does occur. Second, early lists often shrink after case-by-case review. Today’s Florida claim could follow the same track unless the full dataset is released and vetted by independent auditors with county cooperation.
The Verification Challenge: Databases, Errors, And Due Process
Critics warn that federal verification tools are not perfect. The American Immigration Council says the federal Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements program can query databases with outdated entries, which means it is not foolproof for checking immigration status. Past guidance also says a failure to verify through that system does not by itself prove a person is a noncitizen, and voters must get a chance to provide documents or appeal. Those guardrails help protect legal voters, especially new citizens.
Florida officials told a national outlet earlier this year that the state sends counties lists of potential noncitizens for local review, rather than treating a match as final. Alachua County said it removed nine people for noncitizenship since January 2025, after using the verification tool. These facts show the system can work, but it also shows why Florida must separate real cases from false matches. The public needs clarity on which of the 7,035 alleged ballots were actually counted and legally invalid.
What Accountability Looks Like Under President Trump
President Trump’s administration has made secure elections a core promise. Florida’s claim now demands a clear, simple path: show the records, verify each case, and correct the rolls fast. The Joint Task Force should release a privacy-protected spreadsheet tying each removal to the alleged ballots and dates. Counties should confirm citizenship status and ballot count status for each person. State officials should publish referral outcomes and any prosecutions. Sunlight and due process will answer doubters and punish cheaters.
USDOJ Press Release:
Justice Department Sues State of California over Voter List
WASHINGTON — The Justice Department, working with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), today filed a complaint against the State of California over its voter list after determining that more…
— Matthew Kolken (@mkolken) October 16, 2026
Conservatives want two things at once: stop illegal voting and protect legal voters. That balance is common sense. Florida can deliver it now. First, conduct a race-by-race audit to see if any verified illegal ballots could have changed results. Second, tighten registration checks so only citizens get on the rolls. Third, set a fast appeal process so new citizens are never wrongly removed. Clean rolls, honest counts, and quick fixes will restore trust without excuses.
Sources:
thegatewaypundit.com, dailysignal.com, joehoft.com, x.com
